fbpx

Merchant of Doubts

Merchant of Doubts

Mass Media and Society: Merchant of Doubts

            Science and media have similar characteristics; they both collect information and value accuracy and objectively. Objectivity in media excuses sluggish reporting, therefore, rather than focusing on the side that seems favorable, objectivity allows a reporter or a journalist to focus on both sides of the story. Like a journalist, scientists have a standard of conduct that provides a guideline on the kind of behavior expected of them. These standards are usually justified in terms of ethical principle and the goal of the scientists. The public usually benefits when these two institutions complement one another. However, the unfortunate effect of this interaction often results in misguided news that can have adverse consequences to the public. The documentary Merchants of Doubt underscores the interaction between media and science. The documentary traces the public relations strategies used by the tobacco industry to spread confusion on the effect of tobacco and global warming. The primary theme in this documentary is the importance of ethics in media and PR professionals.

In this documentary, director Robert Kenner highlights how pundits-for-hire were used as public relations (PR) professional to refute legitimate scientific research. Public relations started as a professional in the late 19th century, when newsmakers were looking for a way to get their stories told in the press releases and to elaborate public stunt (Croteau and William 61). PR professional offered access to news to the publisher; however, major companies have used the profession to get their views included in their mainstream media and to generate a false impression on numerous scientific controversies.

Kenner demonstrates how PR pundits were used by tobacco, dioxin, and fossil fuel industry to debate or cast some doubt on the research by legitimate scientific research, yet most of these experts did not take part in the scientific research. The documentary traces how these PR experts were paid and introduced to journalists to improve the falling credibility of the industries. Keller notes that corporations are ruthless when using PR firms. Ben Santer, a climate scientist who is highlighted in the film, claims that scientists are not trained to defend the finding of their research. They do not know how to present themselves in the media or to deal with public attacks (Keller). However, paid PR firms are experts on the media and are versed to telling lies that inspire confidence to the listener or viewers. The PR firm eventually injects doubts on real science that do not exist, thereby stalling actions that are bad for the bottom line of the corporations which has hired them. 

 In this film, Keller seems to understand the primary reasons many journalists are swayed by these PR pundits, some of whom are scientists or sounded like scientists even on issues that are beyond their expertise. Notably, media objectivity is of critical importance; thus, a journalist must consider the balance and avoid any form of bias when covering a story. However, given that a dozen of credible scientists are against thousands of these PR experts, who synthesized the initial scientific reporting based on their analysis; a journalist is likely to have a false balance. Oreskes, one of the interviewees in the film and the author who inspired the documentary, posits that the false balance created by the PR is not aimed to serve the issues at hand.  She claims that “sometimes, the evidence and the data are on one side” (Keller). Similarly, one of the scientist in the film states that they have to prove their scientific research while the PR pundits have to sow the seeds of doubt. In other words, interaction with these pundits on the media results in different interpretation, and once an idea is readily accepted, it is open to confusing debates.

Although interviewing PR professionals in the media is a means of providing balance to two opposing viewpoints, numerous ethical issues arise in such debates. According to Croteau and William, it is always crucial for media professionals to decide whether to report or air a story, and the process of deciding determines whom they will be loyal to when reporting (81). That is to say; loyalty determines whether a particular cause is worth reporting or whether a competing loyalty should be a focus. A journalist has the responsibility to determine the direction of his or her loyalty reporting. Given that most of the PR pundits in this documentary were created to discredit scientific research, a journalist should make important ethical choices before reporting any debate that may create disinformation. Ethics is a value system that informs someone what is right or wrong, just or unjust, or fair or unfair. In many professions, a set of principle is needed to guide those in that profession to make better decisions in an ethical dilemma.

Philosophers have tried to draft rules that govern how to make an ethical choice since the day of ancient Greece. In particular, Aristotle believed that practical reason and virtue should guide a person in an ethical dilemma (Croteau and William 9). He believed that following the set rules is not sufficient; therefore, a person has to understand the consequences of their action and act based on the best outcome of a situation. Similarly, Kant asserts that a person must act as if their choices were to become a universal law. His ethical theory is based on the notion that an act is more important than a person acting. Such ethical philosophy helps a media professional to determine the amount or the kind of news that are fit to print or to air on a news media. Croteau and William use the concept of loyalty to help PR professional and journalism choose between two competing allegiances (81). Sorting through competing loyalties is often tricky, especially when one role conflicts with loyalty in another. PR professions are often employed, and this means that they cannot dissipate their organization. It is, therefore, necessary for the PR professional to abide by certain rules or models when deciding on conflicting loyalties.

Public relations strategies have historically been associated with unethical acts, either through lying or through offering falsehoods or involvement in corporate espionage. As such, critics argue that public relations are not subject to any ethical principle because the practice is akin to manipulation. In this documentary, Keller has underscored this kind of playbook developed by Tobacco companies such as the Big Tobacco or the Exxon Mobile to hide the relevant information from the public for their selfish gains. Most of the documentary’s running time is devoted to decades of campaigns funded by oil companies using PR to stall political action or cast doubt on scientific consensus. Similar playbooks were used by denialist to discredit scientific evidence mesh with the PR code of ethics. These companies used disinformation campaigns founded on the principle that media firms are obliged to present both points of view. However, this strategy is deception and only focuses on the corporate bottom line. One particular part of the documentary highlights the strategy used by the large corporation through PR firms to mislead the public on a crucial public health issue. Magician Jamey Ian Swiss used card tricks to demonstrate this PR strategy. The strategy used may seem simple, but like the game cards, Swiss demonstrates how the elements of the game are psychologically powerful. The strategies have been refined for years, and they may seem ethical, but are far from it, and they are often hard for the public to detect.

Some PR professions in this film have violated the code of ethics when they are faced with conflicting loyalties. One of the PR profession mentioned in this film is Marc Morano who gleefully admits in the documentary that he has no any form of scientific training but admits that he plays on TV. Precisely, his primary role is to humiliate scientists during a ‘balanced interview’ on new programs. He then rallies his followers to support the debate creates; therefore, scientific research has no place. For instance, his followers clobbered Bill Nye because he explained a complicated truth about science. As the documentary accentuate, such PR experts use the human vulnerability to underscore the goals from their employer. Morano acted unethically because even though he has no scientific background, he used his agenda in the name of a balanced viewpoint to discredit true scientific facts. The public relation code of ethics is comprised of set rules on how a PR practitioner should behave; this includes upholding the truth and fairness while preserving the right of their client and the responsibility of the public. Morano here does no uphold truthiness; rather, he demonstrates a deliberate intention to mislead.

Undoubtedly, a PR practitioner primary role is it to advocate for the organization, client or their cause, but he or she has a responsibility to serve the public interest. Ethical making model such as Potter Box can help PR professionals to make ethical choices, which means incorporating conflicting loyalties of their client and that of the public. Ralph Potter developed this model, and its initial requires the PR specialist to go through four basic steps before arriving at an ethical judgment. The four steps include understanding the relevant facts, outlining the values that are inherent in the decision, application of relevant principles, and articulating a loyalty (Croteau and William 9). In the case of Morano, the facts are straightforward. He had all the information; therefore, it is his discretion to distort them. Value means considering the truth and privacy of an individual. If the truth means attacking someone’s privacy, then a PR should give up some truth. Once the value has been established, PR applies philosophical principles as outlined by Kent, Aristotle, and other philosophers. The last step in this model is the articulation of loyalties. The PR expert must decide whom his or her loyalty lays, and when there is a conflict of loyalty, Porter claims that a PR expert can maintain a variety of loyalties. In this case, Morano does not seem to have a balance of loyalty. The loyalty of his clients was so dominant that he is forced to abandon his loyalty to the public, which arguably seems more critical.  

Ethical challenges faced by PR professionals and journalists are more complex than in most professional. As noted, objectivity is essential to provide a balance. However, a PR professional must also think about the ethical worthiness of a message. Croteau and William suggest the use of ethical TARES test, which helps a PR officer to deliver the right message, whether when advertising or when on the news (56). The test allows a PR to assess Truthfulness, Authenticity, Respect, Equity, and Social responsibility of the message. If a PR practitioner does not include one of these elements in his or her messages, it is likely he or she will act unethically. Morano and other PR practitioners highlighted in this film are considered unethical because they have not included any of these elements on their message to the public. Precisely, the public needs to know the truth about tobacco and global warming, but Morano does not provide this information. Instead, he distorts credible information to confuse the client. Also, instead of becoming an advocate, he has become adversaries for a social problem. The message delivered by the PR pundits highlighted in this film does not offer equity; they discredit the scientific information knowing that the audience may not be able to interpret the information without prejudice.

In this film, Keller seems to understand the reasons journalists were used by the PR pundits to spread their corporate agenda. One of the key issues this documentary attempts to make is the way media can be complicit to unethical practices by pretending to be objective. Objectivity in media excuses lazy reporting; therefore, instead of a journalist or a reporter focusing on the side that is good enough, objectivity allows them to focus on both sides of the story (Croteau and William 23). The media desire to present both views in a story allows them to include PR pundits in their debates.

In the film, Oreskes claims that the journalists “fall for it lock, stock and barrel” (Keller Film).  Being complicit to these PR pundits emphasized the importance of being cautious when involving PR experts in media coverage. The Potter Box model is one of the frameworks that a journalist can use when reporting a story. One of its critical elements is loyalty. Ideally, the choice of a journalist to use a PR pundit is grounded on ethical reasoning as well as demand. The justification for the demand of the other side of the story is not enough to let a journalist violated his or her loyalty to the public. The responsibility of a journalist is to lay out the fact, and tell the truth and not support any corporate agenda and this includes using the set code of conduct and other available models. Notably, Keller’s documentary is not to blame the media for ethical issues of science. However, the issue underscored on the film indicates the failure of public relation in executing their duty and the failure of the media in helping the public understand science.

Works Cited

Croteau, David, and William Hoynes. Media/Society: Industries, images, and audiences. Sage Publications, 2013.

Kenner, Robert, Merchants of Doubt (Film). Sony Pictures Home Entertainment (Firm), 2015.  

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Tired of Guidelines or Lack Time to Work on Your Paper, Get Original Custom Research Paper Writing Service

Thecustomwriting.com research paper writing service has saved thousands of students from stressful college life. Writing a custom research paper may be challenging, considering it has to be plagiarism-free. And it is better not to do your project than to hand in plagiarized work or hurriedly complete it if you do not have time.

Academic integrity is so vital that you may get a suspension or an expulsion because of a copy-pasted work. Writing a custom research paper requires research and writing skills to produce original content. Here are essential things to know about getting the best and legit assignments help websites.

Perfection is vital

Every website will promise you that they produce high-quality work. However, you put your money for your end-of-semester paper only to get a pass. You must learn how to identify the best writing service before committing.

Thecustomwriting.com produces quality content at all times. Rather than a quality promise, quality assurance is what you should consider before hiring a research writer. Best writing services are reliable. You don't want to partner with a cheap research paper writing service that will deliver poorly written essays hours after the due date.

Quality writers are part of the best writing service. A company that has untrained writers will fail you. Before committing, ensure that the people who will write your paper are academicians and professionals. It would help if you had a writer who will be prompt to respond to your questions and follow instructions. Writers who do not fear to ask for clarification where they don't understand are the best for you.

Beware of Scammers Posing to Provide Custom Research Paper Writing Service

It may take time and effort to find a legit custom research paper writing service. Most of the websites claiming to offer writing service trades your paper with another student. For example, if you order your paper today to submit it next week, you may find that another student has already handed over the same document.

Your money is gone, you have no paper to submit, and the deadline is in two hours. You can only sit and cook up some stories for your lecturer. Otherwise, wait for a penalty or suspension.

Others will give you half-baked papers in the name of cheap essays. Apart from reselling your paper, some companies will offer you copy-pasted work. If you don't have tools such as Turnitin or Copyscape to check plagiarism, you may find yourself in the dean's office explaining why you copied your work from the internet word-to-word.

We offer one of the best research paper writing services in the USA and the U.K.

You won’t regret choosing Thecustomwriting.com to handle your research. Your project is an essential part of your academic work. It determines whether you will move on to the next semester or if your name will appear on the graduation list. Do not gamble your education by hiring any cheap essay writing website you find on the internet. Look for a custom research paper writing service reviews before commit.

Avoid scandals by hiring Thecustomwriting.com. Count yourself lucky if you are reading this article. You are in the right direction in finding the writing service for your paper. Though many websites could have frustrated you, Thecustomwriting.com is committed to providing you with reliable service for your paper.

Thecustomwriting.com offers quality services at affordable prices, and they deliver your work on time. They have native English writers that write your paper using the correct language.

Plagiarism Free Custom Research Paper Writing Service

Our writers understand the seriousness of writing plagiarized papers. Every institution has regulations that govern how a research project is conducted. Universities and colleges take plagiarism as gross misconduct. The best writing services are those that will deliver plagiarism-free papers.

Plagiarism involves, among others, copying a published work and delivering it to your lecturer as your own without acknowledging the sources.

Another way your work can be plagiarized is the failure to include the source of your content in a research paper. If you are using someone's thought, you need to include a reference and in-text citations to show that you are using another scholars' worker.

It's a gross mistake to write a five-page paper without a single source unless the paper's nature does not require you to rely on any sources. Here are some tips our writers use to avoid accidental plagiarism:

  • Cite direct quotes, statistics, and paraphrased content.
  • Ensure that all in-text citations are included in the biography and vice versa.
  • Directly quoting not more than 2% of the paper, if quoting is necessary (some papers are exempted from this rule, especially literature).
  • Stick to high authority, scholarly sources. Our writers will hardly paraphrase content from third party blogs and other questionable sites.
  • Consider Buying A Custom Research Paper from Thecustomwriting.Com

    Consider hiring an expert essay writer if you are not sure about your capabilities. Referencing and citations can be challenging, especially if you try to do it for the first time. It's even harder when your lecturer asks you to use a hard referencing style. For example, Harvard requires you to include page numbers, dates, and the author's name in the text. If you have several papers with a strict deadline, you should consider hiring a custom research paper writing service to help you work on your essays.

    However, ensure the website you want to hire offers legit writing service. A good website should at least charge for its services. You will find many websites willing to provide you with free services. No one is that idle to sit and write a paper for free. Sites that provide free or cheap services hooks you when you least expect.

    Also, consider the price of writing a paper. Though cheap essays are of low quality, other sites may have inflated prices for their rate, making you needlessly break your bank.

    Thecustomwriting.com understands the need for a fair and reasonable price for most students. We know that most students need service, but they do not have enough resources. We, therefore, offer quality service that you can afford.

    Benefits of using custom research paper writing service

    If this is your first time considering using a custom writing service, the first thing is to know why taking such an action is the best. Choosing Thecustomwriting.com ensures professional writers handle your paper. Letting a qualified person handle your project can boost your grade. You cannot afford to fail in the upcoming end-of-semester project. In any case, your progress to the next level will be determined by how well you perform in your essay.

    Thecustomwriting.com ensures the timely delivery of your work. The good thing about legit essay writers is that they can write your essay within the shortest time possible, with one page taking up to one hour at most. It doesn't matter what time you want your work done: Thecustomwriting.com is always ready for a task.

    We will give you a paper written explicitly for you. We will ensure that your paper is not delivered to someone else.

    Come to think of this; if five of your classmates decide to order an essay for the same class, five writers will be assigned to work on different papers instead of paraphrasing one paper and sending it to five of you.

    Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

    Do subject specialist writers handle my research paper?

    It's our responsibility to ensure that someone from your field handles your paper. Our company has enough writers from every discipline. We provide only a research writer qualified in your subject to handle your paper. After placing an order, the first step is to screen the question and requirement and match it with the best writer. The less qualified writer has a college diploma, and they only handle high school papers. All other writers are bachelor, masters, and PhD degree holders.

    Are your researchers qualified enough to know the core of the research?

    We commit to quality content. We understand that failure to deliver quality service will result in the loss of clients. Therefore, we only hire qualified writers who have an in-depth understanding of your paper. Whether you want quantitative research done using Chi-square or qualitative research, Thecustomwriting.com’s writers will comfortably handle any discipline or type of paper. Besides, we offer research paper service from college to PhD. Therefore, we cannot afford to have unqualified writers. Our researchers take every instruction keenly when writing your essay.

    Should I worry about order placement?

    There is nothing to worry about placing your order. Our platform has a simple, user-friendly interface that enables you to navigate to different functionalities with ease. We offer quality custom research paper writing services; thus, you don't have to worry about getting value for your money. Besides, you can track your order's progress. Our system progressively send you email notifications regarding every stage of your orders' progress; thus, you don't even have to log in to track down your order. You will also see the progress on the dashboard when you log in. Moreover, our support team will contact you when the writer needs any clarification.

    Can I have direct communication with the writer after the order placement?

    Our system is designed in such a way that it allows you to communicate with your writer directly. We understand the need to clarify things yourself to the writer. Furthermore, our support team is available 24 hours to ensure that urgent matters are communicated swiftly with the writer.

    Will I get any discount on recommendation?

    The answer is yes. We value your efforts and trust to recommend us to your friends. We will offer you a discount on your next order if a client mentions your email when placing an order.

    What guarantees should customers look for?

    We have a written list of what we guarantee our clients in our terms. We guarantee the quality, confidentiality, free revision, original content, and timely delivery. We also guarantee money-back if, in the unlikely event, you are not happy with the quality of the paper.

    What makes a reliable writing company?

    It's easy to know a reputable company. First, they are transparent about their services. They offer multiple methods of communication and have qualified writers. Most importantly, they deliver your work on time, deliver original content, and honour what they have guaranteed.

    Why should customers not opt for cheap essay writing services?

    Cheap essay services will only waste your time. They have foreign writers who will produce plagiarized content full of grammar errors. You will waste your precious time waiting for a paper that you can't give your lecturer.

    Is buying essays online safe?

    It's safe to buy your essay if you take the right precaution. Before putting your money on a strange site, explore the website to see whether you will get customer reviews. They will help you make the right decision.

    How do I hire someone to write an essay for me?

    These are common questions with most clients. It's effortless to get a professional writer. The first step is to identify a custom research paper writing service that is legit and sign up. After that, they will guide you on how to place your order and get a writer. Some companies will allow you to choose a writer for yourself or choose a writer for you.

    What types of writing services can I order online?

    Our website offers a variety of legit essay services. We provide any academic assistance, including research projects, assignments, and admission letters. Visit our website to see what each service entails.

    What benefits and additional features do Thecustomwriting.com services offer?

    We offer several free services to our customers. We offer free revision, a discount on your first order, and free pages such as references and cover pages. Also, we have a quality control department that ensures that all papers are of high quality before delivering them to you.

    Do websites maintain your privacy? Are orders secured?

    Your privacy is our top priority. You will be recognized by your I.D. assigned to you after signup instead of your name. The only person who can access your account is you or anyone else you give your password. Your payment is through a third party. Therefore, your personal information will never reach our site without your consent.

    What are the pros of ordering from custom writing services?

    You get quality papers. We have writers with decades of experience delivering quality papers worth the client's money and much more. We understand your power to influence our progress. Your paper will be delivered on time and written by professional writers.

    Hire a professional writer

    Now that you know what to look for when considering the custom research paper writing services, it's time to try us. Sign up and get a discount on your first order. You don't have to worry about quality, timely delivery, and price. We know they are essential to you.

    Calculate your order
    Pages (275 words)
    Standard price: $0.00
    Client Reviews
    4.9
    Sitejabber
    4.6
    Trustpilot
    4.8
    Our Guarantees
    100% Confidentiality
    Information about customers is confidential and never disclosed to third parties.
    Original Writing
    We complete all papers from scratch. You can get a plagiarism report.
    Timely Delivery
    No missed deadlines – 97% of assignments are completed in time.
    Money Back
    If you're confident that a writer didn't follow your order details, ask for a refund.

    Calculate the price of your order

    You will get a personal manager and a discount.
    We'll send you the first draft for approval by at
    Total price:
    $0.00
    Power up Your Academic Success with the
    Team of Professionals. We’ve Got Your Back.
    Power up Your Study Success with Experts We’ve Got Your Back.